Amber Heard’s Private Texts with Agent Reveal True Feelings About Elon Musk Relationship During Defamation Trial

During the highly publicized $50 million defamation trial between actor Johnny Depp and his ex-wife Amber Heard, a trove of private communications came to light, offering an intimate glimpse into the actress’s personal life. Among the most revealing were text messages exchanged between Amber Heard and her former agent, Christian Carino. These candid conversations, dating back to 2017, delved into Heard’s relationship and subsequent breakup with the prominent tech entrepreneur, Elon Musk. The texts, read aloud in court, painted a picture of a complex emotional landscape, where Amber Heard reportedly confessed to her agent that she was merely “filling space” during her time with the SpaceX founder, highlighting the intricate dynamics of celebrity relationships under intense media scrutiny.

The text exchange between Heard and Carino became a pivotal piece of evidence, scrutinized by legal teams and the public alike. Carino, who notably also represented Johnny Depp at one point, was questioned extensively about these communications in a pre-recorded deposition. His testimony provided a professional, yet personal, perspective on Heard’s mindset during a tumultuous period of her life. The agent’s recollection corroborated the sentiment within the texts, emphasizing that Heard’s relationship with Musk might not have been as serious or emotionally invested as it appeared from the outside. The revelation of these messages underscored the trial’s deep dive into the private lives of its subjects, aiming to establish the truth behind allegations of defamation.

In one particular exchange, Amber Heard expressed profound sadness, stating she was “dealing with [the] breakup” from Elon Musk. This raw admission of heartbreak offered a rare glimpse into the emotional toll of a high-profile separation. However, Christian Carino’s response in the text exchange suggested a different underlying narrative. He candidly reminded Heard of her previous assertions regarding her feelings for Musk, writing, “You weren’t in love with him, and you told me a thousand times, you were just filling space.” This specific phrase resonated significantly within the courtroom and among observers, implying that Heard might have entered or maintained the relationship for reasons other than deep romantic affection, possibly to cope with the aftermath of her separation from Johnny Depp.

The concept of “filling space” introduces a nuanced layer to the understanding of Heard’s relationship with Musk. It suggests a temporary arrangement or a means of emotional distraction rather than a profound connection. For a celebrity navigating the complexities of public life and personal turmoil, such a dynamic isn’t uncommon. Agents often play a crucial role not only in managing careers but also in advising on personal matters that could impact public image. Carino’s position, having represented both Depp and Heard, lent a unique credibility to his observations, as he was privy to the inner workings of both individuals’ lives and their overlapping narratives. The revelation of these texts raised questions about the authenticity of celebrity relationships and the emotional realities behind the glitzy facade.

Further texts from Amber Heard highlighted her distress over the public nature of her breakup with Musk. Dealing with personal heartbreak is challenging enough, but for a public figure, every detail can become fodder for headlines and public commentary, intensifying the emotional burden. Christian Carino, ever the pragmatic advisor, offered counsel tailored to the unique pressures of celebrity life. He advised the Aquaman actress, “You could avoid all this if you stopped dating über-famous people. You can be with a big man who isn’t famous.” This advice, while blunt, speaks volumes about the constant media scrutiny that follows high-profile individuals and their romantic entanglements. It emphasizes the inherent trade-off between fame and personal privacy, suggesting that a less public partner might offer a semblance of normalcy and shield from relentless press attention.

During his pre-recorded deposition, Carino was pressed to elaborate on his advice. His explanation reinforced the practical implications of his words: “I believe what I was saying was, ‘If you don’t like being in the press about your personal life, then don’t date people that are famous.'” This straightforward clarification underscored the agent’s role in helping clients manage their public image and personal happiness. It highlighted the challenges faced by celebrities who yearn for privacy but are constantly drawn to relationships within their own high-profile circles. The advice served as a stark reminder that while fame brings immense opportunities, it also imposes significant limitations on personal freedom, particularly concerning romantic relationships.

The romantic relationship between Elon Musk and Amber Heard spanned much of 2017, with a brief reunion reportedly occurring in 2018. The timeline of this relationship became a significant point of contention during the Depp-Heard trial, as court documents alleged that the actress and entrepreneur began seeing each other while Heard was still married to Johnny Depp. These allegations fueled speculation and provided context for some of the more explosive claims made during the legal proceedings. The precise start date of their romance was crucial, as it potentially implicated Heard in infidelity during her marriage, a narrative that Depp’s legal team sought to establish. The complex chronology of their relationship, intertwined with the breakdown of her marriage to Depp, became a subject of intense public and legal interest.

Both Amber Heard and Elon Musk have vehemently denied that their relationship began during Heard’s marriage to Johnny Depp. A representative for Elon Musk addressed these claims in a past statement to Vanity Fair, asserting, “Elon and Amber didn’t start seeing each other until May 2016, and even then it was infrequent. Their relationship didn’t become romantic until some time later.” This statement aimed to clarify the timeline and dispel notions of an overlap, though the exact nature and timing of their initial interactions remained a topic of much discussion. The conflicting accounts underscored the challenges of reconstructing timelines in high-stakes legal battles, where personal narratives often clash and every detail is subject to rigorous examination. The public revelation of their dating timeline further complicated the already intricate web of relationships central to the defamation case.

The anticipation surrounding the trial also extended to the list of potential witnesses. Both Elon Musk and actor James Franco were initially included on the list of individuals expected to be called to testify during the defamation lawsuit. Their inclusion hinted at their potential to offer crucial insights into Amber Heard’s relationships and her personal circumstances during various periods relevant to the case. Musk, as a former romantic partner, could have provided firsthand accounts of Heard’s demeanor and the timeline of their relationship, particularly concerning the contentious overlap allegations. Franco’s potential testimony was linked to surveillance footage that showed him with Heard in an elevator around the time of her separation from Depp, leading to speculation about his awareness of her domestic situation.

However, as the trial progressed, it became clear that neither high-profile figure would ultimately take the stand. A source with knowledge of the trial conveyed to the New York Post that neither Musk nor Franco were expected to testify. The reasons for their non-appearance were not explicitly detailed, but it is common for potential witnesses in such high-profile cases to avoid testifying due to scheduling conflicts, a desire to stay out of the media spotlight, or strategic decisions by legal teams who might deem their testimony unnecessary or potentially unhelpful to their case. The absence of these prominent figures from the witness stand left some questions unanswered but did not diminish the intensity or impact of the evidence that was presented, including the revealing text messages that offered a window into Amber Heard’s private world.