Jennifer Aniston vs. Angelina Jolie: The Ultimate Oscar High-Slit Gown Showdown

The Academy Awards red carpet is a runway where fashion history is made, where iconic looks are born, and where certain moments become etched into popular culture forever. Few fashion statements ignite as much conversation and fascination as a strategically placed, show-stopping high-slit gown. It’s a bold choice that commands attention, blending elegance with undeniable allure. And when two of Hollywood’s most powerful and talked-about actresses embrace this daring trend, the world takes notice.

Indeed, we experienced a powerful sense of déjà vu, a delightful flashback to an unforgettable “Oscar leg” moment, when Jennifer Aniston graced the 89th annual Academy Awards in 2017, revealing an impressive amount of leg in a stunning black gown. The striking visual immediately brought to mind another legendary high-slit appearance: Angelina Jolie’s iconic pose at the 2012 Oscars. Both women, clad in sophisticated black dresses, captured global attention with their confident display of leg, but their approaches and the ensuing public reactions couldn’t have been more different. This article delves into these two pivotal red carpet moments, comparing the style, impact, and lasting legacy of Jennifer Aniston’s elegant reveal against Angelina Jolie’s unforgettable, meme-generating pose, and ultimately asks: who truly owned the high-slit look better?

Jennifer Aniston’s Subtle Seduction at the 2017 Oscars

The 2017 Academy Awards held a delightful surprise for fashion enthusiasts as Jennifer Aniston, then 48, made a breathtaking appearance. As a special presenter for the emotional In Memoriam segment, she didn’t walk the traditional red carpet, meaning her grand reveal happened live on stage. This added an extra layer of anticipation, and when she finally stepped into the spotlight, the reaction was immediate and overwhelmingly positive. Aniston exuded effortless glamour in a custom Atelier Versace black sequined gown that meticulously hugged her famed figure. The dress was a masterclass in understated sex appeal, featuring a sleek silhouette that cascaded gracefully, culminating in a dramatic, sky-high slit on her left thigh.

The gown itself was a marvel of craftsmanship. Adorned with countless shimmering sequins, it caught the stage lights beautifully, giving her an ethereal glow. The strategic placement of the slit allowed for a powerful display of her toned leg without appearing overly exposed. What truly set Aniston’s moment apart was her demeanor. She strode confidently to the microphone, her movement fluid and natural, allowing her leg to be glimpsed organically as she moved. There was no forced pose, no exaggerated jutting; simply a graceful, confident movement that showcased the gown’s daring detail in a sophisticated manner. It was a testament to her personal style – always refined, often minimalist, yet capable of delivering powerful fashion statements. Her approach was cool, elegant, and undeniably sexy, cementing her status as a perennial red carpet icon.

This subtle, yet impactful, display immediately sparked comparisons. The black dress, the high slit, the major awards show – it was impossible not to recall another memorable “leg” moment involving an actress with a significant connection to Aniston’s past. The fashion world, and indeed the internet, buzzed with the realization that Aniston had, perhaps inadvertently, stepped into a similar stylistic territory as her “nemesis” Angelina Jolie, revisiting a fashion debate that had captivated millions years prior.

[jwplatform EpaUcy5q]

Angelina Jolie’s Unforgettable Pose: The 2012 Oscar Leg Phenomenon

Five years prior, at the 84th annual Academy Awards in 2012, Angelina Jolie, then 36, delivered a red carpet moment that would transcend fashion and become a full-blown cultural phenomenon. Arriving hand-in-hand with her then-partner, Brad Pitt, the couple was the undisputed center of attention. Jolie wore a stunning black strapless velvet Versace gown that was elegant and statuesque. The dress featured a sophisticated sweetheart neckline and a cinched waist that flowed into a voluminous, structured skirt. However, it was a cleverly concealed, incredibly high slit on her right side that would become the star of the evening.

Unlike Aniston’s more organic reveal, Jolie’s display of her right leg was a deliberate, almost theatrical performance. From the moment she stepped onto the red carpet, she posed with her leg dramatically jutted out, her hand often resting on her hip, drawing maximum attention to the limb. She repeated this pose with unwavering consistency throughout the evening, on the red carpet, during interviews, and even while presenting an award on stage. It was a conscious decision to make her leg the focal point of her entire look, and the world reacted with a mix of awe, amusement, and a touch of bewilderment.

The sheer theatricality of Jolie’s pose instantly launched “Angelina Jolie’s Right Leg” into internet stardom. Memes flooded social media platforms, with countless parodies and humorous recreations popping up within hours. The limb even garnered its own Twitter account, attracting hundreds of thousands of followers almost overnight. Fellow Oscar attendees and presenters couldn’t resist mocking the pose, playfully jutting out their own legs on stage in the wake of Jolie’s presentation. It was a moment that simultaneously celebrated and satirized celebrity culture, demonstrating the power of a single, exaggerated pose to dominate the global conversation.

The dress itself, a custom-made creation by Versace, was undeniably beautiful, a classic Hollywood glamour piece. But it was the way Jolie chose to wear it, or rather, the way she chose to *pose* in it, that made it legendary. The confidence, bordering on defiance, with which she presented her leg became a symbol of her powerful persona. It cemented her image as a daring and impactful presence, ensuring that her 2012 Oscar look would be remembered not just as a fashion statement, but as a cultural touchstone.

The Black Dress, High Slit, and the Brad Pitt Connection: A Deeper Look

The parallels between Aniston’s 2017 and Jolie’s 2012 Oscar moments are striking, extending beyond just the choice of a black, high-slit gown. Both women, celebrated for their beauty and talent, wore designs that emphasized their incredible physiques. Both chose one of the most prestigious nights in Hollywood to make their statement. And, perhaps most notably, both women shared a significant personal history with Brad Pitt. While the “Team Aniston” versus “Team Jolie” narrative had somewhat subsided by 2017, the historical context was undeniable and added another layer of intrigue to Aniston’s similar fashion choice.

The black dress itself is a timeless classic, a symbol of elegance, sophistication, and power. Adding a high slit transforms it from merely elegant to boldly sensual, a deliberate move to showcase a woman’s confidence and physical prowess. For Aniston, the sequined gown represented a radiant, celebratory moment in her career. For Jolie, the velvet Versace epitomized a period of peak power coupling and humanitarian advocacy. Each dress, while sharing a core stylistic element, conveyed a slightly different message tailored to the wearer’s public image and the specific moment in their career.

Who Wore It Better? A Battle of Style and Statement

The question of “who wore it better” isn’t merely about the aesthetics of the dress; it’s about the execution, the attitude, and the lasting impact. Jennifer Aniston’s approach was one of effortless grace. Her leg reveal was almost a happy accident, a natural consequence of her confident stride across the stage. There was no overt attempt to draw attention to it; the leg simply appeared as part of her overall radiant presence. This subtle sexiness is deeply ingrained in Aniston’s brand – she consistently embodies a sophisticated yet approachable allure. Her high-slit moment was an elegant wink, a testament to her enduring appeal without resorting to overt exhibitionism.

Angelina Jolie, on the other hand, made her leg the star of the show. Her pose was a deliberate, almost theatrical act, an unmistakable statement. It wasn’t just a dress; it was an event. This boldness, while sparking countless memes and a divided public reaction, undeniably made her look one of the most memorable in Oscar history. Jolie’s intention seemed to be to command attention, to make a distinct, unignorable statement, and in that, she absolutely succeeded. Her “Oscar leg” became synonymous with daring fashion and celebrity confidence, for better or worse.

In terms of immediate viral impact, Angelina Jolie clearly wins. Her leg became an internet sensation, dominating headlines and social media for days. It was a moment of fashion as performance art, one that transcended mere clothing to become a pop culture phenomenon. Jennifer Aniston’s moment, while stunning, was more about classic beauty and understated elegance, a testament to her consistent good taste rather than a disruptive statement.

From a purely fashion perspective, both dresses were exquisite. Versace, a brand synonymous with high-octane glamour, delivered perfectly for both women. Aniston’s sequined gown offered a shimmering, celebratory feel, while Jolie’s velvet design brought a rich, theatrical elegance. The choice between “better” truly comes down to personal preference: do you prefer the subtle, effortless allure that hints at sexiness, or the bold, unapologetic statement that demands attention?

The Enduring Legacy of the High Slit Gown on the Red Carpet

These two iconic moments underscore the enduring power of the high-slit gown as a red carpet staple. It’s a design that offers a perfect balance of coverage and revelation, allowing designers to create drama while maintaining sophistication. The allure of the high slit lies in its ability to empower the wearer, to project confidence, and to add a dynamic element to even the simplest of silhouettes. It’s a style that has been embraced by countless celebrities, from Rihanna to Bella Hadid, consistently making headlines and inspiring trends.

The “Oscar leg” phenomenon, ignited so vividly by Angelina Jolie and subtly echoed by Jennifer Aniston, highlights how celebrity fashion moments can capture the zeitgeist and become part of our collective memory. These aren’t just dresses; they are narratives, expressions of persona, and catalysts for cultural conversation. They remind us that the red carpet is more than just a walk to an awards show; it’s a stage where fashion and celebrity intersect to create unforgettable moments that resonate far beyond the night itself. Whether it’s the confident strut or the playful pose, the high-slit gown remains a powerful symbol of glamour, daring, and undeniable star power on Hollywood’s grandest stage.