The Society’s Unfortunate End: Kathryn Newton on Allie, Harry, and Unanswered Questions from Netflix’s Canceled Hit

In a shocking blow to its dedicated fanbase, Netflix made the difficult decision to reverse its season 2 renewal for the popular teen mystery drama, The Society. The news, attributed to complications arising from the COVID-19 pandemic, sent ripples of disappointment across social media platforms and fan forums. Just weeks before the planned September 2020 filming start date, Netflix announced the show would not be returning, leaving viewers and critics alike grappling with a multitude of unresolved cliffhangers. The Society had quickly cultivated a massive following, drawn to its compelling premise of a group of teenagers mysteriously transported to a parallel version of their wealthy town, West Ham, where they are forced to establish their own society, New Ham, and navigate the perilous challenges of survival, leadership, and moral decay.

The initial excitement for a second season was palpable. Fans eagerly anticipated answers to the show’s most pressing questions: the fate of Allie, Harry, Grizz, and the rest of the New Ham residents, the true whereabouts of their parents, and the identity of Becca’s baby daddy. The cancellation left a void, prematurely ending a narrative that had just begun to delve into the complex psychological and social dynamics of its young characters. It was a stark reminder of the unprecedented impact the global pandemic had on the entertainment industry, particularly on large-ensemble productions like The Society, which faced significant logistical and safety hurdles.

Among the most passionately debated and beloved pairings to emerge from The Society was the complex relationship between Allie Pressman and Harry Bingham, affectionately dubbed “Hallie” by fans. Their dynamic was a simmering blend of class differences, personal struggles, and undeniable chemistry. While they only shared one intimate encounter, the underlying connection between Allie, the reluctant leader burdened by responsibility, and Harry, the troubled golden boy grappling with addiction and entitlement, never truly faded. Their paths often diverged, pushing them into conflicting roles within New Ham’s nascent society, yet moments of vulnerability consistently highlighted their deep-seated bond. A poignant example was Allie’s selfless act of visiting Harry during his severe depressive episode, offering comfort and unwavering support when he was at his lowest. Many “Hallie” shippers still recall the powerful, unspoken intimacy of Allie touching Harry’s hand, a gesture he reciprocated by sweetly grasping her arm—a small interaction that conveyed volumes about their unspoken understanding and affection.

In an exclusive conversation with HollywoodLife, series star Kathryn Newton, who portrayed the tenacious Allie Pressman, offered her definitive take on the potential future of Allie and Harry. When asked about whether the pair would have ultimately ended up together, Newton’s response was unequivocal. “One hundred percent they are endgame. That’s it. They’re meant to be. They’re meant to be together,” she affirmed to HollywoodLife while promoting her then-upcoming horror-comedy, Freaky. This confirmation provided immense validation for “Hallie” fans, suggesting that despite their season 1 estrangement and Harry’s involvement in the coup against Allie, a narrative path towards reconciliation and a lasting relationship was indeed envisioned by those involved with the show. It speaks to the enduring power of their connection, hinting at a potential journey of redemption for Harry and a deeper understanding between the two leaders.

Kathryn Newton openly admitted her desire for more “Hallie content” in season 2, expressing her fondness for working with co-star Alex Fitzalan. “Alex [Fitzalan] is amazing, and we had so much fun,” Newton shared. She elaborated on the unique joy actors experience when their characters resonate deeply with the audience, fostering passionate fan communities. “It’s just fun when the fans ship you, and you can have fun with it. That brought us so much joy when you see that two characters or any character you play resonate with people. You just feel a lot of love from that.” This sentiment underscores the profound bond that forms between actors, their characters, and the audience. Even in the face of cancellation, the outpouring of fan love became a source of comfort for the cast. “So even when the show got canceled, we were like crying almost tears of joy to feel how much people love the show and the characters that we played,” Newton revealed, highlighting the bittersweet emotions of ending a beloved project while feeling the immense appreciation from its dedicated viewers.

The first season of The Society concluded with a series of dramatic twists and a laundry list of unanswered questions, leaving fans on the edge of their seats and eagerly anticipating resolution. The most significant development was the ruthless coup orchestrated by the manipulative Campbell, with the unwitting aid of Harry, Lexie, and the Guard. This power play successfully dethroned Allie as mayor of New Ham, leading to her unjust arrest alongside her ally, Will. In a shocking reversal of power, Harry and Lexie were subsequently installed as co-mayors, signaling a dark turn for the fragile society. For “Hallie” shippers, myself included, there was a glimmer of hope that Harry’s involvement might be a convoluted, secret scheme to ultimately protect or save Allie, a theory rooted in his complicated affection for her, even amidst his ambition and susceptibility to Campbell’s influence. His internal conflict and past connection with Allie fueled speculation that his actions might have been more nuanced than they appeared on the surface, perhaps setting the stage for a dramatic redemption arc in a potential second season.

Beyond the political upheaval, another major cliffhanger revolved around the highly anticipated birth of Becca Gelb’s baby. The father of Becca’s child remained a tantalizing mystery throughout the season, a secret that Kathryn Newton herself was desperate to uncover. “I just want to know who Becca’s baby daddy is. Legitimately, who is it?” Kathryn exclaimed, echoing the sentiments of countless viewers. This question wasn’t merely a point of curiosity but a significant plot device, promising to expose underlying tensions and relationships within the isolated community. Speculation ran rampant, with many pointing fingers at Sam, Becca’s best friend, or even Grizz, who had developed a strong bond with Sam. The revelation of the father’s identity would undoubtedly have had profound implications for Becca, her child, and the broader social fabric of New Ham. Newton also expressed her confidence in Allie’s resilience, adding, “And I felt like Allie was going to be the queen once again, so I wasn’t too worried about her taking their crown back.” This suggests that despite her arrest and dethronement, Allie’s leadership qualities and her capacity to fight for justice would have ultimately led her to reclaim her rightful place, potentially initiating a compelling power struggle against the new, less legitimate regime.

Despite the abrupt cancellation and the heartbreak that followed, Kathryn Newton refuses to give up hope that The Society could one day return and provide closure for its loyal fanbase. Her optimism stems from a deep appreciation for the show’s narrative and the powerful community it fostered. “I definitely hope the story gets finished for the fandom that we’ve created. I love the fans and The Society so much. I love my cast. I think that will last forever,” Newton passionately stated. The cast formed a strong bond during their time together, sharing both the triumphs and tribulations of creating such a unique series. “We were all heartbroken when we found out we weren’t going to be able to finish the season,” she confessed, highlighting the shared disappointment of seeing their collaborative effort cut short.

Newton continues to hold onto the possibility of a continuation in some form, suggesting alternative formats that could bring the story to its rightful conclusion. “So I’m hoping that there’s some way, maybe like a podcast or anything like that,” she mused. This idea, while unconventional, speaks to the creative flexibility that could allow the complex narrative of New Ham to be explored without the full logistical challenges of a television series. The power of fandom, Newton believes, is a force strong enough to influence such outcomes. “If I’ve learned anything from the power of fandom it’s that if they ask, they will receive. So if they keep asking, maybe we can finally make something happen.” This echoes the sentiment seen in other fan-led campaigns that have successfully brought beloved shows back from the brink, such as *Veronica Mars* or *Sense8*. The continued dedication of The Society’s fans, their unwavering engagement with the characters and unresolved plotlines, remains the strongest beacon of hope for a potential revival. Whether through a limited series, a film, or a podcast, the desire to see Allie, Harry, and the rest of the New Ham teens find their way home, or at least conclude their compelling journey, remains a fervent wish for many, including its devoted stars.