Spencer Pratt Leverages Cody Simpson’s Sweet Serenade to Miley Cyrus for Fresh Shade at Kaitlynn Carter

In the ever-evolving landscape of celebrity relationships and public feuds, few figures manage to stir the pot quite as consistently as Spencer Pratt. Known for his unfiltered opinions and penchant for drama, The Hills: New Beginnings star has once again captivated audiences, this time by cleverly using a romantic gesture from Cody Simpson to Miley Cyrus as ammunition in his long-standing rivalry with Kaitlynn Carter. This latest incident, sparked by a hospital bedside serenade, underscores the complex dynamics within the reality TV and music industries, proving that old grievances rarely fade away, especially when social media provides a convenient platform for their resurgence.

It’s an open secret among fans and followers of reality television that Spencer Pratt holds a deep-seated disdain for his The Hills: New Beginnings co-star, Kaitlynn Carter. For years, Pratt has openly blamed Carter for what he perceived as a wedge driven between him and his former close friend, Brody Jenner, during the six years Jenner and Carter were together. This long-simmering resentment has frequently spilled into public view, and now, Pratt has found a fresh and strikingly public way to express his displeasure, targeting Carter through her recent high-profile romance with global pop sensation, Miley Cyrus. The context for this latest dig came as Miley Cyrus, 26, was recuperating in the hospital from a bout of tonsillitis. During her recovery, her new boyfriend, Australian singer Cody Simpson, 22, made headlines with a truly heartwarming gesture: he visited her, bearing flowers and serenading her with his guitar, a tender moment that quickly went viral across social media platforms.

The intimate moment between Cyrus and Simpson was captured and shared on E!’s Instagram page, showing Cody gently strumming his guitar while Miley, visibly touched, lay in her hospital bed. It was beneath this very video, a testament to budding romance and thoughtful companionship, that Spencer Pratt chose to make his move. His comment was succinct yet potent: “Yah Kaitlynn def couldn’t do that.” This seemingly innocuous statement immediately struck a chord with fans, who quickly recognized it as a deliberate and pointed jab at Carter. The reaction was swift and overwhelmingly positive from Pratt’s followers, with his comment accumulating over 1,800 likes and generating a wave of enthusiastic responses. Users flocked to express their amusement and approval, with comments like “goodbye this comment has me dead 😂,” from a user named Tay, and Molly’s addition of “howling at this comment,” illustrating the immediate comedic impact. Another fan, Alex, simply wrote “dayum, shade lol,” while Kelly lauded Spencer’s audaciousness, telling him “@spencerpratt you’re fricken savage😂.” These reactions highlight Spencer Pratt’s unique ability to connect with his audience through controversial, yet often entertaining, public statements.

This isn’t Spencer Pratt’s first foray into publicly criticizing Kaitlynn Carter, nor is it the most surprising given his established history with her. Even before Miley and Kaitlynn embarked on their brief, six-week romantic fling in August, Pratt was vocal about his opinions regarding Carter following her split from Brody Jenner. The timing of their separation, just ahead of Carter’s highly publicized hookup with Cyrus, provided Pratt with ample material for commentary. On August 3, during an episode of his and wife Heidi Montag’s popular “Make Speidi Famous Again” podcast, Spencer, 36, addressed the Brody-Kaitlynn breakup, stating unequivocally, “I’m not surprised.” He further elaborated on his long-held belief about their relationship dynamic, suggesting, “I feel like I said it, maybe it hasn’t aired yet, but that he almost was like a hostage. It felt like he was trying to tell me, ‘Get me out. Get me out.’” Adding another layer to his critique, Pratt didn’t shy away from labeling Kaitlynn as “controlling,” a characterization he has consistently maintained throughout their public interactions.

Spencer Pratt’s Unwavering Disdain for Kaitlynn Carter: A Long-Standing Feud

The animosity between Spencer Pratt and Kaitlynn Carter is not a new development, nor is it merely a superficial reality TV skirmish. It traces back years, originating from Spencer’s belief that Kaitlynn actively contributed to the estrangement between him and Brody Jenner, a friendship he clearly valued. Throughout the seasons of The Hills: New Beginnings, this underlying tension has been a recurring theme, often bubbling to the surface in confrontational scenes or candid confessionals. Spencer’s “hostage” comments and accusations of “controlling” behavior were not isolated incidents but rather consistent themes in his public discourse about Kaitlynn.

In a memorable July 9 episode of The Hills, Spencer launched into a particularly fiery rant concerning Kaitlynn and her relationship with Brody. “The guy is f**king clearly controlled like a f**king puppet,” he exclaimed, referring to Brody Jenner under Kaitlynn’s perceived influence. Pratt then contrasted this dynamic with his own relationship, asserting his independence: “I love my wife, I love my baby, but I’m not a drone. You can’t control me.” His frustration stemmed not only from what he saw as Kaitlynn’s manipulative tendencies but also from a feeling of exclusion. Spencer highlighted his long-standing social isolation from the couple, lamenting, “Kaitlynn doesn’t like me. In 5 years of them being together, they have a lot of parties and I see a lot of people at them and I’ve never been invited to one of them.” This perceived snub further solidified Spencer’s antagonistic view of Kaitlynn, painting her as a gatekeeper who deliberately distanced him from Brody.

The dramatic turn of events in the summer of 2019—Brody and Kaitlynn’s split, followed almost immediately by Kaitlynn’s whirlwind romance with Miley Cyrus—provided Spencer with fresh ammunition and a renewed sense of validation for his long-held opinions. For Spencer, Kaitlynn’s quick transition into another high-profile relationship, especially one that drew significant media attention, only seemed to underscore his narrative of her being a certain type of person. Now, with Kaitlynn out of the picture in terms of her romantic involvement with Brody, there might be a glimmer of hope, at least from Spencer’s perspective, for him to mend his fractured friendship with Brody. The question remains whether Brody shares this desire and if the deep-seated resentments, fueled by years of Spencer’s public commentary, can truly be overcome.

The Significance of Cody Simpson’s Serenade

Cody Simpson’s serenade to Miley Cyrus was more than just a sweet gesture; in the context of Spencer Pratt’s ongoing feud, it became a powerful symbol. The act itself—a boyfriend visiting his ailing partner in the hospital, bringing flowers, and offering a personal, heartfelt performance—is universally understood as a tender, romantic, and deeply caring display. By contrasting this with his perception of Kaitlynn Carter, Spencer implicitly suggests that such a profound and selfless act of affection is beyond her capacity or, perhaps, that she is incapable of inspiring such a gesture from a partner. This comparison subtly elevates Cody Simpson’s actions while simultaneously diminishing Kaitlynn, playing perfectly into Spencer’s established narrative about her character and her relationships.

Miley Cyrus’s brief but intense romance with Kaitlynn Carter, which occurred in the wake of Miley’s separation from Liam Hemsworth and Kaitlynn’s split from Brody Jenner, was a major headline-grabber. Their public displays of affection and their seemingly inseparable bond captivated the media and fans alike. However, the relationship was short-lived, concluding just before Miley’s new connection with Cody Simpson blossomed. This timeline is crucial because it provides Spencer with a direct comparison. While Kaitlynn and Miley’s relationship was certainly passionate and public, it didn’t feature the kind of traditionally “romantic” and nurturing gestures that Cody’s hospital visit embodied. Spencer’s comment leverages this difference, implying a perceived lack in Kaitlynn’s relational style or emotional depth, further cementing his personal vendetta.

The Power of Social Media in Celebrity Feuds

Spencer Pratt’s use of an Instagram comment to deliver his shade is a perfect illustration of how social media platforms have fundamentally reshaped celebrity interactions and feuds. In the past, such digs might have been confined to magazine interviews or veiled remarks on television. Today, platforms like Instagram, Twitter, and TikTok allow celebrities to engage directly, instantly, and often brutally. This directness fosters a sense of authenticity, even when the comments are clearly designed for maximum impact and controversy. Spencer Pratt, a master of self-promotion and public perception, understands this dynamic implicitly. His comments, while provocative, are rarely without purpose; they keep him relevant, generate headlines, and solidify his “villain” or “anti-hero” persona that resonates with a significant portion of his fanbase.

The viral spread of Spencer’s comment, amplified by celebrity gossip accounts like “Comments By Celebs,” demonstrates the powerful feedback loop of social media. A simple, well-placed remark can explode into a wider conversation, drawing in thousands of reactions and sparking debates among fans. This constant stream of interaction means that celebrity feuds are no longer episodic events but ongoing narratives, played out in real-time for public consumption. For Spencer, this is not just about settling personal scores; it’s about maintaining his brand as an outspoken, no-holds-barred personality who isn’t afraid to speak his mind, regardless of the consequences. This strategic use of social media allows him to stay in the public eye, generate buzz for himself and The Hills: New Beginnings, and continuously shape the narrative around his relationships with co-stars.

Looking Ahead: What Does This Mean for the Hills Stars?

With Kaitlynn Carter now romantically uninvolved with Brody Jenner, and her fleeting relationship with Miley Cyrus also a thing of the past, the landscape of “The Hills” cast’s personal lives has shifted considerably. Spencer Pratt’s latest jab, while aimed squarely at Kaitlynn, also implicitly hints at his desire for a renewed connection with Brody. For years, the tension between Spencer and Kaitlynn directly impacted Spencer’s friendship with Brody. With that perceived obstacle removed, the door might open for a reconciliation between the two long-time pals. However, Brody Jenner has his own history with Spencer, and their friendship has seen many ups and downs even before Kaitlynn entered the picture. It remains to be seen whether Brody will be willing to move past the past and embrace a rekindled bond with Spencer, especially given Spencer’s consistent public commentary. The drama, it seems, is far from over for the stars of The Hills: New Beginnings, and Spencer Pratt continues to be at the very heart of it all.